Somerset this week: 21 June 2024
The MP you elect on 4th July could help shape the future of food and farming in Somerset. So what kind of change do they want to enact? We invited Hugh Thomas from the Wallfish Journal to tell us more
Dear readers
This week I’d like to welcome food writer Hugh Thomas from the Wallfish Journal to these pages to give his take on the General Election.
I’d also like to welcome our new subscribers, we’ve had quite a few in the past fortnight. Welcome, thank you for signing up and please do encourage friends, family and colleagues to join our merry band!
Journalism without adverts, is most people agree, a lot more readable than journalism with adverts.
But journalism without adverts, whether it is in a newspaper or delivered online, needs your financial support to keep going. We are all used to paying for a newspaper and online news content is no different.
Even so we still provide a lot of content for free. You can subscribe here to get that free copy:
However if you feel like helping us pay our bills (and helping us do more investigative journalism into the bargain) then please consider taking a paid subscription.
For 58p a week, that’s less than a third of the price of the Western Gazette:
4 extra articles a month
the chance to have your say, to comment argue and debate our articles
full access to our back catalogue (it is getting bigger every week)
and the satisfaction of supporting one of Somerset’s most innovative journalism projects.
Where else can you get quality local journalism that rests on our three core values of: questioning, investigating and telling truth to power?
If you’d like to support us with a paid subscription you can do that here. If you are enjoying what we do, please tell your friends and encourage them to subscribe too!
Thank you.
Andrew Lee - Editor
Somerset this week: 21 June 2024
This week Hugh Thomas is writing for us about the candidates in this election and their appetite for policies about food. Hugh is a food writer who produces The Wallfish Journal, also on Substack.
He covers much the same geographical area as Somerset Confidential® and we follow his Substack and keep in touch with him about food related matters in Somerset. If you want to know why “Wallfish” or to read more of Hugh’s writing about food and farming in Somerset, then please check out his substack page and if you like what you see, subscribe to support his work.
General Election on a plate
by Hugh Thomas
In case it wasn’t obvious already, food and farming is one of the biggest topics on the political agenda this General Election on July the 4th.
That might read as a terribly bold statement, but is so only until you realise how much of what we eat and how we produce it affects various other areas of policy-making. What is, for example, one of the best ways to help alleviate pressure on the NHS? As The Food Foundation will tell you, start by curbing the influence of junk food.
And how, for instance, might Parliament take meaningful action on the UK’s species-depleted countryside and horrendously polluted rivers? One way would be to incentivise farmers to look after them.
Some of these concerns are especially applicable to a county like Somerset. If it is correct that, as Countryside Alliance chief executive Tim Bonner has said, "The countryside will be a key electoral battleground" this election, then Somersetians living in rurality (48% of the county’s population, on last count) may well find themselves in the trenches.
It is that kind of electorate, either with first-hand farming experience or living among the effects of it, that can dramatically change the outcome of who represents them in Parliament come July 4th. If the electorates in the now seven Somerset constituencies covered by the Somerset Council area do indeed see a profound importance in food and farming policy, then they will post their ballot with a tick next to the name of the candidate exhibiting a keen interest in the various aspects of food, and who they think will stand up and campaign in the House of Commons for its betterment, if not directly affect food policy according to what future they believe in for Somerset and the UK.
Whether that ‘future’ vision of theirs is a positive one is down to the interpretation of each voter. You might believe, as some candidates do, that Somerset or the UK at large needs to produce more and cheaper food to feed itself, even if that means upscaling the use of agrochemicals detrimental to nature. Or you might be, as some candidates are, in a very different camp – one that curtails emphasis on monocultural, pesticide-dependent crop production in a way that would likely necessitate trade within the EU Single Market once again.
Naturally, some right-leaning politicians like Jacob Rees-Mogg (who’s standing for the newly-formed North East Somerset and Hanham constituency this election) would baulk at the latter. The Toryman has a peculiar but telling attitude towards food and farming, that can perhaps be summed up by an episode a farmer in the Somerton and Frome constituency recently related to me.
In short, said farmer took Rees-Mogg on a tractor ride round his Somerset farm, then, the next day, Rees-Mogg stood up at a Tory party conference to proclaim, with no hint of irony, that hormone-injected beef, which “should be allowed here” from Australia, was “absolutely delicious”.
This is the same Rees-Mogg who in 2010 told the House of Commons: “Of course I want farming to be sustainable and of course I want people to eat British meat.” And, locally too for he added: “If they have any sense they will buy their meat from Somerset, which is well-known for providing the best and most glorious cuts of meat in the world.”
Let’s return to our seven constituencies in our patch of Somerset. By so many methods these days, voters can get an idea of who stands for what based on a candidate’s party politics. Or, better yet (and among the particularly passionate ones), their personal manifesto. Which is why, leading up to this election, I’ve asked six local candidates hoping to represent Somerset constituencies how they’d campaign for issues relevant to food and farming in their respective region, or the UK as a whole.
Of course, a ring round every party office of every local constituency would be a little too exhausting, so consider this a mere taste of which Somerset candidates for Parliament will stand up for what.
Pelé Barnes – owner of Somerset-based cheesemonger Gouda Karma and Independent candidate for Bridgwater:
“I'm looking to set up something to tackle supermarkets – their prices, waste, expenses on plastic packaging for fruit and veg, and their effect on farmers’ wages.
It's Somerset that people think of when talking about farmers. We can lead by example, starting with more small businesses investment. Bring back the high street by filling up empty buildings and ex-charity shops, vape shops, etcetera, which in turn will lead to direct buying from farms, like I do with my small business Gouda Karma.
There's so much I'd like to get involved with for farmers. I've grown up with them, went to school with them, and have a farmer as my landlord for my business.”
Martin Dimery – Somerset councillor, ex-teacher, former creative director of Frome Festival, and Green candidate for Frome and East Somerset:
“Farmers have been utterly betrayed by Brexit. It is vital we return to the European Single Market in order to give them full access to European markets, without barriers.
We need to reintroduce the kind of EU subsidies that enable them to farm responsibly with a guaranteed income. We cannot allow them to be undercut by cheap, inferior quality imports. Farmers are also the custodians of the countryside. Our ability to reach Net Zero depends on giving them maximum support.”
Sarah Dyke – farmer's daughter, outgoing MP for Somerton and Frome, and Liberal Democrat candidate for Glastonbury and Somerton:
“I have made standing up for Somerset’s farmers one of my key priorities – The UK has lost more than 110,000 farms since 1990, and we only eat 17% of fruit and 55% of vegetables that are grown in the UK. More and more farmers are considering quitting the industry due to huge financial and mental strains, so we have lots to do in order to save British farming.
If we do not tackle these issues, we will be less food secure, families across the country will be unable to access the healthy, locally produced food they need, and farmers who act as custodians of our countryside will lose their businesses.
Farmers are the natural custodians of our countryside, so it is imperative that we provide them with adequate support to ensure we reverse biodiversity decline. This is something that I have been keen to stress in Parliament, where I have championed Somerset Wildlife Trust’s efforts in working with farmers around Somerset to protect crucial habitats for wildlife.
In Parliament I have also been keen to highlight Somerset’s lowland farmers, who have been terribly affected by constant flooding over the last 18 months. We urgently need new natural flood protections, which is why the Liberal Democrats will pay farmers and landowners for creating them with our new, properly funded Environmental Land Management schemes.”
Ian Liddell-Grainger – former farmer, army major, and property developer; outgoing MP for Bridgwater and West Somerset; and now Conservative candidate for Tiverton and Minehead:
“I would put food security first and foremost. As my record shows I have already campaigned vociferously for the UK to become more self-sufficient in food. Importing at least 40% of what we eat is not only costly, it is reckless in an age where world food stocks are under threat on so many fronts, whether from war or weather extremes caused by climate change.
We must intensify production here by harnessing the skills of UK farmers and making best use of our land.
We also need to halt the drift of farmers into environmental schemes merely because they can earn more than they can by growing food. To do that we have to reshape national farming policy – and bring back a stand-alone Ministry of Farming and Food.
We must jump on the supermarkets, legislating to ensure they pay primary producers a 10% margin over and above the cost of production and forbidding them to discount food at a price below production cost.”
Joe Joseph – shepherd, environmental consultant, former lecturer in ‘Agriculture, Countryside and Food’, and Labour candidate for Wells and Mendip Hills:
“I'm Convenor of the West Country Labour and Co-operative Farming, Fisheries and Food (3F) group, which has been informing the development of Labour policy in recent years. Our 3F principles are: food sovereignty; economic democracy; ecological sustainability; and devolution of power to communities. In short, it's about boosting local production and consumption and promoting our great regional produce.
Our Labour manifesto includes a commitment that at least 50% of public food procurement for schools and hospitals will be from local or environmentally certified sources. We will promote 'growing, buying and selling more in Britain', increasing food security and supporting West Country producers.
My personal commitment would be to work with other Parliamentarians for Agroecology to secure a great future for our food system. I would be strongly promoting policies that provide resilient supply chains, high environmental and animal welfare standards, and affordable nutritious food from local suppliers.
Our Co-operative Party policy to 'double the size of the co-operative sector' has been embraced by Labour and that too will be a priority for me, promoting food and farming co-operatives throughout the region.”
Laura Bailhache – lawyer and Reform candidate for Yeovil:
“I’m delighted to be standing in Yeovil where the best dairy produce in the country is made. Reform UK will increase the farming budget to £3 billion; scrap ‘green’ subsidies that encourage the use of productive pasture land for industrial projects such as solar farms or vanity projects like ‘rewilding’.
Reform UK will protect country sports which do so much to boost the countryside and rural communities. Reform UK will give the Competition and Markets Authority the power to stop supermarket price fixing and impose zero business rates on farm shops.”
Hopefully some food for thought there.
Editor’s note: We will be publishing the full list of candidates for the General Election in the seven constituencies we cover next week (so hopefully it will be fresh in your mind when you go to vote) along with the issues as we see them effecting our patch. If you can’t wait until then you can find the list of candidates here.
We hope you have enjoyed reading this edition of Somerset Confidential®. If you enjoy reading our newsletters why not gift someone you know a subscription to Somerset Confidential®?
If you enjoyed this edition, please feel free to share it……
I have been asked by a friend to put the following comment to you:-
"This is a good read, but there is an error in the caption: "Low hanging fruit, but we only eat 17% of what we grow" i.e. we export 83% of the food we grow.
Whereas what Sarah Dyke said was "... we only eat 17% of fruit and 55% of vegetables that are grown in the UK". So in other words we import 83% of the fruit we eat, which is very different."
Best regards
Adrian Dalziel